This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more

Independent buying guide · Prices checked November 21, 2026

MATTRESSES:

Sink in, or sleep on top?

Compare 21 Queen options from soft to firm: memory foam, hybrid and latex mattresses, plus toppers, with the height and materials of each. Amounts are approximate, in US dollars.

  • 16 mattresses + 5 toppers
  • Firmness as each listing says
  • Independent comparison
Made bed with a mattress and pillows in a bright bedroom
Photo: Pexels. Illustrative; brands shown may not be in our picks.

Not sure? Go with one of these

The most reviewed mattress in three feels, by Amazon ratings as of 28 October 2026. We have not tested them, and a rating does not tell you how a mattress will feel to you: this is a starting point. Check the trial and return terms. Not ready for a new mattress? See the toppers in the filters below.

Medium firm: most reviewed

Zinus 12" Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress, Queen

A 12-inch green tea memory foam mattress. 4.3 stars from 91,648 ratings, the most of any mattress here.

Medium hybrid: most reviewed

Signature Design by Ashley 12" Hybrid Mattress, Queen

A 12-inch hybrid with foam over wrapped coils and a euro top. 4.3 stars from 33,368 ratings, the most among the medium picks.

Soft: most reviewed

Amazon Basics Soft Plush Memory Foam Mattress, 10", Queen

A 10-inch, three-layer plush memory foam mattress. 4.4 stars from 8,217 ratings, the most among the soft picks.

About this guide

Start with the feel you like, then compare 16 Queen mattresses from soft to firm (memory foam, hybrid and latex) plus 5 toppers, using published product information from Amazon listings.

We are not paid by brands to feature or recommend them. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through our affiliate links. We have not personally tested these mattresses. Firmness is how each seller describes it; there is no single industry scale.

Compare the feels: pros and cons

Firmness and materials are what the listings state, not results from a sleep test.

Soft mattress with pillows

Soft / plush

What counts in its favor

  • Sink in a little
  • More cushioning on top

What counts against it

  • Less surface support feel
  • Feel depends on your weight

A good fit if you like a cushioned bed.

Medium mattress in a bedroom

Medium

What counts in its favor

  • A balance of cushion and support
  • A common middle ground for couples

What counts against it

  • Not soft, not firm
  • Firmness words differ by brand

A good fit if you share the bed or are not sure.

Medium firm mattress

Medium firm

What counts in its favor

  • A little firmer, still cushioned
  • The most reviewed picks here

What counts against it

  • Firmer than many expect
  • Check the trial

A good fit if you like a firmer feel with some give.

Firm mattress

Firm

What counts in its favor

  • Sleep on top, not in
  • Hybrids with reinforced edges

What counts against it

  • Can feel hard to some
  • Heavier hybrids

A good fit if you like a firm surface.

Mattress topper on a bed

Topper

What counts in its favor

  • Changes the feel of your bed
  • Much less to spend and to move

What counts against it

  • Does not fix sagging
  • Adds height to the bed

A good fit if your mattress is fine but the feel is not.

Photos: Pexels. Illustrative; brands shown may not be in our picks.

Soft / plushMediumMedium firmFirmTopper
FeelSink in a littleA balanceFirmer, some giveOn top, not inChanges your bed’s surface
Main trade-offLess surface feelA middle groundFirmer than many expectCan feel hard to someDoes not fix sagging
What to check before buying
  1. Feel. Firmness is the seller’s description. Two “medium firm” mattresses can feel different.
  2. Memory foam, hybrid or latex. Foam contours, a hybrid adds coils for bounce, and latex responds faster.
  3. Height. A taller mattress may need deeper sheets. Check your sheets and bed frame.
  4. Trial and returns. Check each seller’s trial and return terms before you buy.
  5. Delivery. Most arrive compressed in a box and need up to 72 hours to expand, according to the listings.
Waking up sore? What to check

If you often wake up stiff or sore, the mattress is one of the things worth checking. These checks will not fix a medical problem, but they help you see whether your bed suits you.

  1. Does it sag? A dip where you sleep is a sign the mattress is worn. A topper does not fix sagging.
  2. How old is it? Many people replace a mattress after several years; check the warranty terms for yours.
  3. Firmness for your weight. The same mattress feels firmer to a lighter person and softer to a heavier one.
  4. Room to try. A published trial period lets you sleep on it for a while and return it if it does not suit you.

If you wake up in pain often, talk to a doctor. A mattress is not a treatment, and we cannot tell you which one will relieve pain.

What this comparison is based on

We identify the exact model, height and materials using the linked Amazon listings, read on 28 October 2026. Seller promises are quoted only when they are about comfort or pressure, and always attributed.

Our picks to consider

About the amounts

“From” amounts are approximate starting points we checked on Amazon and rounded down. Prices change often, and sales such as Black Friday can move them a lot, so check the current price, seller, size, delivery date and returns before you buy. Ratings are as of 28 October 2026. All picks are Queen. Toppers only appear under “Any” in the material filter.

Candidates for different needs, grouped by feel and ordered by approximate starting amount, not a ranking.

Soft / plush: sink in a little

A softer surface with more cushioning on top. Firmness is how each listing describes it; how a mattress feels to you also depends on your weight and how you sleep.

Soft / plush
from $210Pillow top

Novilla 12" Hybrid Mattress with Pillow Top, Queen

Why consider it: you want a plush top with springs underneath.

★ 4.3 · 3,857 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 12-inch hybrid with comfort foam over individually pocketed coils and a pillow top, described as medium plush. It arrives compressed in a box.

Key specs:
Height: 12 in
Material: Hybrid: foam over pocket coils
Firmness (listing): Medium plush
Extra: Pillow top

Main compromise: the weight shown in the listing looks inconsistent with its size, so check the shipping details before you order.

Soft / plush
from $215All foam, soft

Novilla 12" Gel Memory Foam Mattress, Queen

Why consider it: you want an all-foam bed with a softer feel and a choice of heights.

★ 4.3 · 1,801 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 12-inch all-foam mattress with NanoGel memory foam on top, described as medium to medium plush, with CertiPUR-US certified foam. Other heights are sold in the same listing.

Key specs:
Height: 12 in
Material: Gel memory foam
Firmness (listing): Medium to medium plush
Extra: CertiPUR-US foam, 61.5 lb

Main compromise: memory foam has a slow, sink-in feel that not everyone likes, and it has fewer reviews than the Zinus models.

Soft / plush
from $255Softest feel

Amazon Basics Soft Plush Memory Foam Mattress, 10", Queen

Why consider it: you want the softest feel described in this guide, from a widely reviewed listing.

★ 4.4 · 8,217 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 10-inch, three-layer memory foam mattress with a plush feel: a memory foam top, a ventilated middle layer and a convoluted base, with CertiPUR-US certified foam and an Oeko-Tex certified top fabric.

Key specs:
Height: 10 in
Material: Memory foam, 3 layers
Firmness (listing): Plush
Extra: CertiPUR-US foam, Oeko-Tex top fabric

Main compromise: a plush feel is not for everyone, and 10 inches is on the thinner side here.

↑ Back to the filters

Medium: a balance of cushion and support

Neither soft nor firm, as described in each listing. A common middle ground if you share the bed or are not sure what you like.

Medium
from $205Fiberglass free (listing)

Zinus 10" Cooling Essential Memory Foam Mattress, Queen

Why consider it: you want a simple medium all-foam mattress.

★ 4.3 · 6,384 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 10-inch gel memory foam mattress with a medium feel and a breathable cover. The listing says it is fiberglass free.

Key specs:
Height: 10 in
Material: Gel memory foam
Firmness (listing): Medium
Extra: Fiberglass free (listing), 56.8 lb

Main compromise: the cooling wording is the maker’s own, and 10 inches is thinner than the 12 and 14-inch picks.

Medium
from $270Most reviewed hybrid

Signature Design by Ashley 12" Hybrid Mattress, Queen

Why consider it: you want a hybrid from a well-known furniture brand, with the most reviews among the hybrids here.

★ 4.3 · 33,368 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 12-inch hybrid with gel memory foam and high-density foam over wrapped coils, a euro top and a medium feel. The listing says the coils add edge support.

Key specs:
Height: 12 in
Material: Hybrid: gel foam over wrapped coils
Firmness (listing): Medium
Extra: Euro top, 76 lb

Main compromise: about 76 lb to move.

Medium
from $280Euro top hybrid

Novilla 14" Hybrid Gel Memory Foam Mattress, Queen

Why consider it: you want springs, a medium feel and a thick profile.

★ 4.3 · 1,187 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 14-inch hybrid with gel memory foam over individually pocketed coils, a euro top and a medium feel. The seller says the coils are arranged in support zones.

Key specs:
Height: 14 in
Material: Hybrid: gel foam over pocket coils
Firmness (listing): Medium
Extra: Euro top, 82 lb

Main compromise: fewer reviews than the Ashley hybrid, and it is heavy (about 82 lb in the listing).

Medium
from $320Thick all foam

Novilla Bliss 14" Gel Memory Foam Mattress, Queen

Why consider it: you want a thick all-foam mattress from a widely reviewed listing.

★ 4.4 · 28,786 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 14-inch, three-layer gel memory foam mattress with a medium feel and a breathable knit cover.

Key specs:
Height: 14 in
Material: Gel memory foam, 3 layers
Firmness (listing): Medium
Extra: Knit cover

Main compromise: the review count is shared with the 12-inch Bliss listing, and all-foam has a sink-in feel.

Medium
from $400Trial and warranty

Casper Element 10" Memory Foam Mattress, Queen

Why consider it: you want a known mattress brand with a published trial and warranty.

★ 4.4 · 6,090 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 10-inch memory foam mattress with a medium feel and CertiPUR-US certified foam, with a 100-night trial and a 10-year warranty.

Key specs:
Height: 10 in
Material: Memory foam
Firmness (listing): Medium
Extra: 100-night trial, 10-year warranty

Main compromise: a 10-inch all-foam mattress, thinner than several picks here.

↑ Back to the filters

Medium firm: a little firmer, still cushioned

A firmer feel with some give on top, as described in each listing. The Zinus Green Tea mattresses are the most reviewed in this guide.

Medium firm
from $17010-inch classic

Zinus 10" Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress, Queen

Why consider it: you want a widely reviewed brand in a 10-inch profile.

★ 4.3 · 22,364 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 10-inch green tea memory foam mattress with a medium firm feel. It arrives compressed and the listing allows 24 to 72 hours to regain its shape.

Key specs:
Height: 10 in
Material: Memory foam with green tea
Firmness (listing): Medium firm
Extra: 53 lb

Main compromise: the 12-inch version has many more reviews, and the foam needs time to expand.

Medium firm
from $195Green tea foam

EGOHOME 10" Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress, Queen

Why consider it: you want a medium firm all-foam mattress.

★ 4.3 · 13,556 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 10-inch gel memory foam mattress with green tea in the foam and a medium firm feel.

Key specs:
Height: 10 in
Material: Gel memory foam with green tea
Firmness (listing): Medium firm
Extra: Tight top

Main compromise: fewer reviews than the Zinus Green Tea, and 10 inches is on the thinner side.

Medium firm
from $220Most reviewed

Zinus 12" Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress, Queen

Why consider it: you want the most reviewed mattress here, in a 12-inch profile.

★ 4.3 · 91,648 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 12-inch green tea memory foam mattress with a medium firm feel and a breathable knitted cover. It is the most reviewed mattress in this guide.

Key specs:
Height: 12 in
Material: Memory foam with green tea
Firmness (listing): Medium firm
Extra: Knitted cover, 62.3 lb

Main compromise: an all-foam feel, and the seller’s description of its zones is its own.

Medium firm
from $385Graphite cover

EGOHOME 14" Copper Gel Memory Foam Mattress, Queen

Why consider it: you want a thick medium firm foam mattress with a cooling-focused cover.

★ 4.4 · 6,179 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 14-inch memory foam mattress with copper gel memory foam, a medium firm feel and CertiPUR-US certified foam. The seller describes its graphite-infused cover as cool to the touch.

Key specs:
Height: 14 in
Material: Copper gel memory foam
Firmness (listing): Medium firm
Extra: Graphite-infused cover, CertiPUR-US, 84 lb

Main compromise: heavy (about 84 lb in the listing).

↑ Back to the filters

Firm: sleep on top, not in

Less sink, more surface, as described in each listing. Firmness is subjective, so check each seller’s trial and return terms before you buy.

Firm
from $225Reinforced edge

Avenco SyncDeep 12" Firm Hybrid Mattress, Queen

Why consider it: you want a firm feel with springs.

★ 4.4 · 1,106 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 12-inch firm hybrid with gel memory foam and high-density foam over pocketed coils, a euro top and a reinforced edge.

Key specs:
Height: 12 in
Material: Hybrid: foam over pocket coils
Firmness (listing): Firm
Extra: Euro top, reinforced edge, 72 lb

Main compromise: fewer reviews than most picks here.

Firm
from $370Thick and firm

FP FLEXPEDIC 14" Firm Hybrid Mattress, Queen

Why consider it: you want a thick firm hybrid with a reinforced edge.

★ 4.4 · 1,427 ratings on Amazon, shared across FP FLEXPEDIC sizes

See details

According to the listing, a 14-inch firm hybrid with gel memory foam and high-density foam over coils, a euro top and reinforced perimeter coils.

Key specs:
Height: 14 in
Material: Hybrid: foam over coils
Firmness (listing): Firm
Extra: Euro top, reinforced edge, 93 lb

Main compromise: the review count is shared with other FP FLEXPEDIC listings, and it is heavy (about 93 lb in the listing).

Firm
from $660One-year trial

Nectar Classic 12" Memory Foam Mattress, Firm Feel, Queen

Why consider it: you want a well-known mattress brand with a long published trial and a firm feel.

★ 4.3 · 1,210 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 12-inch memory foam mattress with a firm feel and a one-year trial.

Key specs:
Height: 12 in
Material: Memory foam
Firmness (listing): Firm
Extra: 1-year trial (listing)

Main compromise: an all-foam mattress, so it feels different from the firm hybrids.

Firm
no offer right nowLatex

Sunrising Bedding 8" Natural Latex Hybrid Mattress, Queen

Why consider it: you want latex, which has a springier, quicker-responding feel than memory foam.

★ 4.3 · 673 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, an 8-inch mattress that combines natural latex with individually encased pocket coils, described as firm.

Key specs:
Height: 8 in
Material: Natural latex over pocket coils
Firmness (listing): Firm
Extra: Tight top

Main compromise: at 8 inches it is the thinnest mattress here, and it has the fewest reviews in this guide.

↑ Back to the filters

Toppers: not ready for a new mattress?

A topper goes on top of the mattress you already have and changes how the surface feels. It does not fix a mattress that sags; in that case, compare the mattresses above.

Topper
from $33Soft and washable

Niagara Sleep Solution Ultra Soft Mattress Topper, Queen

Why consider it: you want a soft, washable layer.

★ 4.3 · 62,356 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a pillow-top style topper with a cover made from rayon derived from bamboo, deep pockets for mattresses 8 to 20 inches, and a washable design.

Key specs:
Height: Not listed
Material: Fiber fill, rayon from bamboo cover
Firmness (listing): Soft
Extra: Deep pocket (8–20 in), washable

Main compromise: a fiber topper adds softness rather than foam support, so check your mattress depth.

Topper
from $423 inches of foam

OLIXIS 3" Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper, Queen

Why consider it: you want a thick foam layer.

★ 4.4 · 1,769 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 3-inch gel-infused memory foam topper with ventilation holes and CertiPUR-US certified foam. The seller says it is designed to relieve pressure points and soften a firm bed.

Key specs:
Height: 3 in
Material: Gel memory foam
Firmness (listing): Plush
Extra: Ventilated, CertiPUR-US

Main compromise: fewer reviews than the Linenspa, and the foam may need time to expand.

Topper
from $47Most reviewed topper

Linenspa 2" Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper, Queen

Why consider it: you want the most reviewed topper here.

★ 4.5 · 75,016 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 2-inch gel memory foam topper with a plush feel; other heights are sold in the same listing. The seller says it is designed to soften a mattress that feels too firm.

Key specs:
Height: 2 in
Material: Gel memory foam
Firmness (listing): Plush
Extra: Other heights in the listing

Main compromise: check that the height you select is the one you want.

Topper
from $135Denser foam

ViscoSoft 3" Select High Density Memory Foam Topper, Queen

Why consider it: you want a thicker, denser topper with a medium-firm feel.

★ 4.4 · 15,238 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 3-inch memory foam topper with a medium-firm feel and a foam density of over 3 pounds per cubic foot.

Key specs:
Height: 3 in
Material: Memory foam, 3+ lb density
Firmness (listing): Medium firm
Extra: Higher-density foam

Main compromise: a denser foam is heavier to move and to fit on the bed.

Topper
from $155TEMPUR material

Tempur-Cloud 2" Mattress Topper, Queen

Why consider it: you want TEMPUR material without buying a whole mattress.

★ 4.1 · 12,504 ratings on Amazon

See details

According to the listing, a 2-inch topper made of TEMPUR material with a medium feel and a machine-washable cover. The seller says it is designed to absorb pressure and reduce motion transfer.

Key specs:
Height: 2 in
Material: TEMPUR memory foam
Firmness (listing): Medium
Extra: Washable cover, 16 lb

Main compromise: 2 inches, and the lowest average rating among the toppers here.

↑ Back to the filters

Torn between two? Four comparisons

Four close calls from the picks above, side by side. Based on the listings, not a hands-on test.

Specs at a glance: all 21 side by side

As described in the listings; check the exact size and height before buying.

MattressTypeHeightMaterialFirmness (listing)From
Novilla 12" Pillow TopSoft / plush12 inHybrid: foam over pocket coilsMedium plush$210
Novilla 12" Gel FoamSoft / plush12 inGel memory foamMedium to medium plush$215
Amazon Basics 10" PlushSoft / plush10 inMemory foam, 3 layersPlush$255
Zinus 10" Cooling EssentialMedium10 inGel memory foamMedium$205
Ashley 12" HybridMedium12 inHybrid: gel foam over wrapped coilsMedium$270
Novilla 14" HybridMedium14 inHybrid: gel foam over pocket coilsMedium$280
Novilla Bliss 14"Medium14 inGel memory foam, 3 layersMedium$320
Casper Element 10"Medium10 inMemory foamMedium$400
Zinus 10" Green TeaMedium firm10 inMemory foam with green teaMedium firm$170
EGOHOME 10" Green TeaMedium firm10 inGel memory foam with green teaMedium firm$195
Zinus 12" Green TeaMedium firm12 inMemory foam with green teaMedium firm$220
EGOHOME 14" Copper GelMedium firm14 inCopper gel memory foamMedium firm$385
Avenco 12" Firm HybridFirm12 inHybrid: foam over pocket coilsFirm$225
FP FLEXPEDIC 14" FirmFirm14 inHybrid: foam over coilsFirm$370
Nectar 12" Firm FeelFirm12 inMemory foamFirm$660
Sunrising 8" LatexFirm8 inNatural latex over pocket coilsFirmNo offer
Niagara Ultra Soft topperTopperNot listedFiber fill, rayon from bamboo coverSoft$33
OLIXIS 3" topperTopper3 inGel memory foamPlush$42
Linenspa 2" topperTopper2 inGel memory foamPlush$47
ViscoSoft 3" topperTopper3 inMemory foam, 3+ lb densityMedium firm$135
Tempur-Cloud 2" topperTopper2 inTEMPUR memory foamMedium$155
Which feel suits you?
  • You like to sink inA soft or plush mattress.
  • You share the bed or are not sureA medium mattress, a common middle ground.
  • You want firmer, with some giveA medium firm mattress.
  • You want to sleep on top, not inA firm mattress; hybrids add a reinforced edge.
  • Your mattress is fine but the feel is notA topper.

Check the current listing, the seller, the size, delivery and returns before you buy.

Questions before you choose (FAQ)
  • What does “medium firm” mean?It is the seller’s description of the feel. There is no single industry scale, so two “medium firm” mattresses can feel different.
  • Memory foam or hybrid?Memory foam contours and lets you sink in; a hybrid adds coils under the foam for a bouncier feel. Neither is better in general.
  • What is a mattress in a box?A mattress that is compressed and rolled for delivery. It expands after you unbox it; the listings allow up to 72 hours.
  • Do I need a topper?Only if your mattress is in good shape but the feel is not right. A topper does not fix sagging.
  • I keep waking up sore. Is it my mattress?It can be worth checking for sagging and the firmness (see “Waking up sore?” above). If you wake up in pain often, talk to a doctor.
  • Has DSH tested these mattresses?No. The comparisons are based on published product information.

Your next step

Match the mattress to the feel you like

Compare the feels, check the height, materials and trial, and choose the exact model before buying.