Ad · This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more

Independent buying guide · Prices checked 16 November 2026

SKILLETS:

Eggs every morning, or a steak on Saturday?

Start with what you cook most, then compare 15 frying pans in three materials: cast iron, nonstick and stainless steel. Amounts are approximate, in pounds.

  • Three materials, 15 pans
  • Check your hob first
  • Independent comparison
Skillets hanging from hooks above a kitchen counter
Photo: Pexels. Not a product photo.

Not sure? Go with one of these

The most reviewed pick in three types, by Amazon.co.uk ratings from late October or early November 2026. We have not tested them: this is a starting point. Want another type? Use the filters below.

Cast iron: most reviewed

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, 26 cm (10.25 inch)

For when you want the classic all-round cast iron pan with the longest review history. 4.6 stars from 72,088 ratings, the most of any pick here.

Nonstick: most reviewed

Tramontina Non-Stick Frying Pan, 25 cm, Removable Silicone Handle

For when you want a well-reviewed everyday non-stick pan from a well-known brand. 4.6 stars from 26,587 ratings, the most among the nonstick picks.

Stainless steel: most reviewed

Tramontina Grano 3-Ply Stainless Steel Frying Pan, 26 cm

For when you want a fully clad pan from a well-known brand, with the most reviews in this group. 4.3 stars from 3,955 ratings, the most among the stainless steel picks.

About this guide

A good frying pan is the one you reach for every day, so the right material depends on what you cook most and how much care you want to give it. Cast iron, nonstick and stainless steel can all earn a place in a home kitchen, but they ask for different habits.

This guide compares materials and published product information from Amazon.co.uk listings. We have not personally tested these pans.

We are not paid by brands to feature or recommend them. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through our affiliate links. We have not personally tested these products.

Start with what you cook most

Eggs, pancakes and delicate fish: a nonstick surface makes release easier with less fat, as long as you keep to the heat and utensil limits in the instructions.

Searing, browning and oven finishes: cast iron and stainless steel tolerate higher heat and can usually go from hob to oven. Check the exact oven-safe temperature for the model, including the handle.

Pan sauces and everyday sauteing: stainless steel builds browned bits that dissolve into a sauce. It can stick if the pan is not preheated and oiled, which is a technique to learn rather than a defect.

Compare the materials
Empty cast iron pan on a wooden table
Cast ironHolds heat well and goes from hob to oven.
Red-rimmed nonstick frying pan on a gas hob
NonstickEasy release for delicate foods and quick cleanup.
Stainless steel pan with a lid
Stainless steelDurable and great for browning and pan sauces.

Photos: Pexels. Illustrative; brands shown may not be in our picks.

These are practical trade-offs to consider, not results from a hands-on cooking test.

Cast ironNonstickStainless steel
Why consider it?Holds heat well; tolerates high heat; suits hob-to-oven cookingEasy release for delicate foods; quick cleanupDurable; handles high heat; good for browning and pan sauces
Main compromiseHeavy; needs drying and re-oiling to protect the seasoningCoating wears over time; heat and utensil limits applyFood can stick without preheating and fat; more scrubbing
CleanupWash, dry right away, wipe with a thin coat of oilUsually gentle washing; follow the maker’s adviceOften dishwasher-safe per the maker; may need a cleanser for stains
InductionGenerally works (magnetic)Only if the base is induction-compatible; check the modelWorks if the base is magnetic; check the model
LifespanCan last for decades with careShorter; plan to replace when the surface no longer releasesLong, with care
What to check before buying
  1. Size: a 24 to 26 cm pan suits one or two people; a 28 to 30 cm pan gives room for family portions but takes more space and weighs more. Check the cooking surface, not just the rim.
  2. Weight and handles: cast iron is heavy, especially when full. A helper handle makes lifting easier. Check whether handles get hot and whether the pan fits your oven.
  3. Hob type: confirm induction compatibility if you have an induction hob. On glass or ceramic hobs, lift rather than slide heavy pans, following the hob maker’s advice.
  4. Oven-safe temperature: it varies by model, handle material and lid. Do not assume every pan tolerates the same heat.
  5. Care routine: choose the cleanup you will actually do. A pan that needs drying and oiling is a poor fit for someone who wants everything in the dishwasher.
  6. Utensils: most nonstick pans need wooden, silicone or nylon tools unless the maker states otherwise. Cast iron and stainless steel are more forgiving.
  7. Stainless construction: some stainless pans have an aluminium disc in the base; others are “clad” or tri-ply, with an aluminium core bonded through the base and up the sides. Both are designed to spread heat; compare the construction described for the exact model.
Choose a setup that fits your kitchen

One pan only: pick the material that matches what you cook most often. For a mixed routine, many home cooks start with one nonstick pan for eggs and one cast iron or stainless pan for searing.

Building a small set: combine materials rather than buying three of the same kind. Different surfaces cover different jobs.

Long-term investment: cast iron and stainless steel can last for many years with care. Nonstick is more of a replaceable tool, so match the investment to how long you expect to use it.

Check the current listing, seller, included lid, delivery date and returns before buying.

What this comparison is based on

We identify the exact product using the linked Amazon.co.uk listings. Our practical suggestions are editorial interpretations of those listings, not hands-on tests. Claims in the listings are the sellers’ own.

Our picks to consider

About the amounts

“From” amounts are approximate starting points we checked on Amazon.co.uk and rounded down. Prices change often, and sales such as Black Friday can move them a lot, so check the current price, seller, size, delivery date and returns before you buy. Ratings were read on the Amazon.co.uk listings in late October or early November 2026 and may be shared across sizes or colours of a listing.

Candidates for different needs, grouped by type and ordered by approximate starting amount, not a ranking.

Cast iron: searing, baking and pans that last for decades

Holds heat well and goes from hob to oven. Heavy, and it needs drying and light oiling after washing. Enamelled cast iron skips the seasoning routine.

Cast iron
from £13Pouring lips

VonShef Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, 10 inch

Why consider it: you want a small pre-seasoned pan with pouring lips.

★ 4.2 · 3,256 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, a pre-seasoned 10 inch cast iron skillet with pouring lips, for all hob types and the oven.

Key specs:
Detail: Cast iron
Size: 10 in
Lid: No

Main compromise: a less established brand, and the usual drying and oiling routine.

Cast iron
from £13Everyday size

nuovva Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, 25 cm

Why consider it: you want a 10 inch cast iron pan.

★ 4.3 · 3,740 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, a pre-seasoned 25 cm (10 inch) cast iron skillet for the hob, oven and grill.

Key specs:
Detail: Cast iron
Size: 25 cm
Lid: No

Main compromise: a less established brand, and it is heavy.

Cast iron
from £15KICHLY 26 cm

KICHLY Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, 26 cm, two handles

Why consider it: you want a pre-seasoned cast iron pan.

★ 4.3 · 8,584 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, a pre-seasoned 26 cm (10.25 inch) cast iron skillet with two handles, suitable for induction and the oven, at about 2.15 kg. The listing says it is not dishwasher safe.

Key specs:
Detail: Cast iron
Size: 26 cm
Lid: No

Main compromise: it is heavy, a less established brand, and it needs drying and light oiling after washing.

Cast iron
from £37Most reviewed

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, 26 cm (10.25 inch)

Why consider it: you want the classic all-round cast iron pan with the longest review history.

★ 4.6 · 72,088 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, a pre-seasoned 26 cm skillet with pouring lips, for induction, the oven, grill and campfire, made in the USA, at about 2.4 kg. It is the most reviewed pan in this guide.

Key specs:
Detail: Cast iron
Size: 26 cm
Lid: No

Main compromise: it is heavy, and stock was low when we checked.

Cast iron
from £96Enamelled premium

Le Creuset Signature Enamelled Cast Iron Skillet, 23 cm

Why consider it: you want cast iron without the seasoning routine, in a colour that can go to the table; a classic gift.

★ 4.4 · 6,380 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, an enamelled cast iron skillet with a helper handle and two pouring lips, 23 cm, made in France, suitable for ovens, grills and all hob types including induction.

Key specs:
Detail: Enamelled cast iron
Size: 23 cm
Lid: No

Main compromise: enamel can chip if dropped.

↑ Back to the filters

Nonstick: eggs, pancakes and quick cleanup

Easy release for delicate foods with less fat. The coating wears over time, and heat and utensil limits apply; check induction compatibility for your hob.

Nonstick
from £12Smallest

Tefal Comfort Max Frying Pan, 20 cm (Thermo-Spot)

Why consider it: you want a small pan for an egg or a pancake, with a heat indicator.

★ 4.5 · 2,620 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, a 20 cm pan with a non-stick coating, a Thermo-Spot heat indicator, a stainless steel body with an induction-compatible base, dishwasher safe, at about 0.6 kg.

Key specs:
Detail: Nonstick, steel body
Size: 20 cm
Lid: No

Main compromise: the small size limits portions, and the coating wears over time.

Nonstick
from £15Blackmoor 28 cm

Blackmoor 28 cm Ceramic Non-Stick Frying Pan (PFAS-free)

Why consider it: you want a ceramic non-stick surface for eggs and everyday cooking.

★ 4.5 · 15,722 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, a 28 cm ceramic non-stick pan described as PFAS-free, for induction, gas, electric and ceramic hobs, with a stay-cool handle, at about 0.8 kg. The listing says it is not oven safe or dishwasher safe.

Key specs:
Detail: Ceramic nonstick
Size: 28 cm
Lid: No

Main compromise: the listing says it is not oven-safe or dishwasher-safe, and a coating like this wears over time.

Nonstick
from £26Stainless body

Jamie Oliver by Tefal Stainless Steel Non-Stick Frying Pan, 28 cm

Why consider it: you want a pan with a stainless body, an oven-safe handle and a non-stick surface.

★ 4.6 · 17,047 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, a 28 cm stainless steel pan with a titanium-reinforced non-stick coating, a Thermo-Signal heat indicator, induction compatibility, oven safe and dishwasher safe, with a 10-year guarantee, at about 1.3 kg.

Key specs:
Detail: Nonstick, steel body
Size: 28 cm
Lid: No

Main compromise: the coating still wears over time, and stock was low when we checked.

Nonstick
from £33Most reviewed

Tramontina Non-Stick Frying Pan, 25 cm, Removable Silicone Handle

Why consider it: you want a well-reviewed everyday non-stick pan from a well-known brand.

★ 4.6 · 26,587 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, a 25 cm aluminium frying pan with a three-layer non-stick interior and a removable red silicone handle, dishwasher safe, with a 1.9 litre capacity and a 90-day warranty. It is the most reviewed non-stick pan in this guide.

Key specs:
Detail: Nonstick
Size: 25 cm
Lid: No

Main compromise: the listing mentions electric, gas and ceramic glass hobs, not induction.

Nonstick
from £46Deepest

SENSARTE 30 cm Deep Non-Stick Frying Pan with Lid (4.7 L)

Why consider it: you cook larger portions, sauces or one-pan meals and want a lid included.

★ 4.4 · 19,652 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, a 30 cm deep non-stick frying pan of 4.7 litres with a lid and a helper handle, a Swiss non-stick coating and an induction-compatible base. The listing says it is not oven safe.

Key specs:
Detail: Nonstick, deep
Size: 30 cm
Lid: Yes

Main compromise: a large, deep pan takes more storage space, and it is not oven-safe according to the listing.

↑ Back to the filters

Stainless steel: browning, pan sauces and everyday sauteing

Uncoated, durable and good with high heat. Food can stick without preheating and fat, which is a technique to learn rather than a defect.

Stainless steel
from £37Jamie Oliver Cook Smart

Jamie Oliver by Tefal Cook Smart Stainless Steel Frying Pan, 28 cm

Why consider it: you want a simple way to learn browning and pan sauces with an uncoated pan.

★ 4.3 · 878 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, an uncoated 28 cm stainless steel pan with a Thermo-Fusion base, induction compatibility, a riveted handle, oven safe and dishwasher safe, at about 1.2 kg.

Key specs:
Detail: Stainless, uncoated
Size: 28 cm
Lid: No

Main compromise: food sticks without proper preheating, and it has fewer reviews than the more established lines here.

Stainless steel
from £43Most reviewed

Tramontina Grano 3-Ply Stainless Steel Frying Pan, 26 cm

Why consider it: you want a fully clad pan from a well-known brand, with the most reviews in this group.

★ 4.3 · 3,955 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, a 26 cm (2.2 litre) three-ply pan (stainless steel, aluminium, stainless steel) for induction, electric, gas and ceramic glass hobs, oven safe and dishwasher safe, at about 1.1 kg. It is also sold in 20 and 30 cm.

Key specs:
Detail: Stainless, tri-ply
Size: 26 cm
Lid: No

Main compromise: there is no lid in this listing, and the usual stainless learning curve: preheat, add fat and let food release.

Stainless steel
from £48Deep, with lid

DELARLO 27.9 cm Triple-Ply Stainless Steel Frying Pan with Lid

Why consider it: you want a deep stainless pan with a lid for sauces and one-pan meals.

★ 4.6 · 369 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, a 27.9 cm triple-ply stainless steel pan of 3.5 litres with a lid, for induction, oven safe up to 315 °C, at about 2 kg.

Key specs:
Detail: Stainless, tri-ply
Size: 27.9 cm
Lid: Yes

Main compromise: a less established brand, and the shape is deeper than a standard frying pan.

Stainless steel
from £81Made in Germany

Fissler Original Profi Collection Frying Pan, 28 cm

Why consider it: you want a premium stainless pan made in Germany.

★ 4.7 · 207 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, a 28 cm stainless steel pan with a satin finish, made in Germany, suitable for induction and the oven, at about 1.8 kg.

Key specs:
Detail: Stainless
Size: 28 cm
Lid: No

Main compromise: no lid in this listing, and the stainless learning curve.

Stainless steel
from £1105-ply

Made In 12 inch Stainless Steel Frying Pan (5-ply)

Why consider it: you want a heavier 5-ply clad pan from a specialist cookware brand.

★ 4.3 · 1,119 ratings on Amazon.co.uk

See details

According to the listing, a 12 inch (about 30 cm) five-ply stainless clad pan made in Italy, induction compatible and oven safe, at about 2 kg.

Key specs:
Detail: Stainless, 5-ply
Size: 30 cm (12 in)
Lid: No

Main compromise: no lid in this listing, and the stainless learning curve.

↑ Back to the filters

Torn between two? Four comparisons

Four close calls from the picks above, side by side. Based on the listings, not a hands-on test.

Specs at a glance: all 15 side by side

As described in the listings; check the exact model before buying.

PickTypeDetailSizeLidFrom
VonShef 10 inchCast ironCast iron10 inNo£13
nuovva 25 cmCast ironCast iron25 cmNo£13
KICHLY 26 cmCast ironCast iron26 cmNo£15
Lodge 26 cmCast ironCast iron26 cmNo£37
Le Creuset SignatureCast ironEnamelled cast iron23 cmNo£96
Tefal Comfort MaxNonstickNonstick, steel body20 cmNo£12
Blackmoor 28 cmNonstickCeramic nonstick28 cmNo£15
Jamie Oliver by TefalNonstickNonstick, steel body28 cmNo£26
Tramontina 25 cmNonstickNonstick25 cmNo£33
SENSARTE deepNonstickNonstick, deep30 cmYes£46
Jamie Oliver Cook SmartStainless steelStainless, uncoated28 cmNo£37
Tramontina GranoStainless steelStainless, tri-ply26 cmNo£43
DELARLO triple-plyStainless steelStainless, tri-ply27.9 cmYes£48
Fissler Original ProfiStainless steelStainless28 cmNo£81
Made In 5-plyStainless steelStainless, 5-ply30 cm (12 in)No£110
Which type suits you?
  • Eggs, pancakes and delicate fishA nonstick pan.
  • Searing, cornbread and oven finishesA cast iron skillet.
  • Browning and pan saucesA stainless steel pan.
  • A gift for a home cookEnamelled cast iron or a clad pan.

Check the current listing, the seller, the size, delivery and returns before you buy.

Questions before you choose (FAQ)
  • Can I use metal utensils?On cast iron and stainless steel, generally yes. On nonstick, only if the maker explicitly allows it.
  • Does cast iron need seasoning?Many pans come pre-seasoned, but the seasoning improves and is protected with use, drying and light oiling. Follow the maker’s instructions.
  • Why does food stick to stainless steel?Usually because the pan or the fat was not hot enough, or the food was moved too soon. Preheat, add fat, and let the food release on its own.
  • How long does a nonstick pan last?It depends on heat, utensils and cleaning. Replace it when the surface no longer releases food as expected or the coating is visibly damaged.
  • Is one material the best?No. Choose by what you cook, your hob and the care you are willing to give. Each material solves a different problem.
  • Has DSH tested these products?No. The comparisons are based on documented product information from the Amazon.co.uk listings.

Your next step

Choose the one that fits you

Compare the types, check the details and choose the exact model before buying.